Rexxie

Elimination: Tier 10 - E5 Triumphant! (COMPLETE)

863 posts in this topic

Edit: Elimination over! Kudos to everyone who voted! Results here.

One thing this forum has never had is an elimination thread! If you're unfamiliar how these topics work, let me explain - I'll give you a list of choices with a number after them. From them, you increase the "best" choice by 1 and decrease the "worst" choice by 3. Each user is allowed to do this a maximum of once per day. You must explain your choices, even if very briefly. When a choice hits 0, it is eliminated. I'll keep track of in what order they were eliminated in the OP, and the end result is some form of interactive community aggregate ranking! Pretty neat. Highlight your increase with GREEN and your decrease with RED.

Let's start this out with tier 10! Non-techtree T10s are not included both because most people can't accurately judge them and because the list is too long as it is.

1 TANKS REMAINING

121            ELIMINATED
113            ELIMINATED
TVP T50/51     ELIMINATED
Foch 155       ELIMINATED
AMX 50B        ELIMINATED
Batchat 25t    ELIMINATED
AMX 30B        ELIMINATED
Waffentraiger  ELIMINATED
Jagdpz E-100   ELIMINATED
Maus           ELIMINATED
E-100          ELIMINATED
E-50M          ELIMINATED
Leopard 1      ELIMINATED
STB-1          ELIMINATED
Type 5 Heavy   ELIMINATED
Centurion AX   ELIMINATED
FV215b 183     ELIMINATED
FV215b         ELIMINATED
FV4005         ELIMINATED
T57 Heavy      ELIMINATED
T110E4         ELIMINATED
T110E3         ELIMINATED
M48 Patton     ELIMINATED
T110E5         VICTOR
Object 268     ELIMINATED
Object 263     ELIMINATED
T-62A          ELIMINATED
Object 430     ELIMINATED
Object 140     ELIMINATED
IS-7           ELIMINATED
IS-4           ELIMINATED

Elimination Order:

Spoiler
  1. Type 5 Heavy
  2. FV4005
  3. Waffentrager
  4. Foch 155
  5. Jagdpz E-100
  6. FV215b 183
  7. Object 268
  8. 121
  9. AMX 30B
  10. Maus
  11. T110E4
  12. T57 Heavy
  13. Leopard 1
  14. Object 263
  15. T110E3
  16. Object 430
  17. 113
  18. Centurion AX
  19. IS-7
  20. STB-1
  21. IS-4
  22. Object 140
  23. Batchat 25t
  24. E-50M
  25. T-62A
  26. E-100
  27. FV215B
  28. AMX 50B
  29. M48 Patton
  30. TVP T50/51

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

21: 20
113: 20
TVP T50/51: 20
Foch 155: 20
AMX 50B: 20
Batchat 25t: 20
AMX 30B: 20
Waffentraiger: 20
Jagdpz E-100: 21 Because I like the armor and alpha profile, can be lolzworthy (even if I don't fire HEAT).
Maus: 20
E-100: 20
E-50M: 20
Leopard 1: 20
STB-1: 20
Type 5 Heavy: 17 Having played the Type 4 this is my vote. If it it marginally improves the Type 4 it will still be utter shit (gun, mobility, armor, all of it is pretty damn useless).
Centurion AX: 20
FV215b 183: 20
FV215b: 20
FV4005: 20
T57 Heavy: 20
T110E4: 20
T110E3: 20
M48 Patton: 20
T110E5: 20
Object 268: 20
Object 263: 20
T-62A: 20
Object 430: 20
Object 140: 20
IS-7: 20
IS-4: 20

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

21: 20
113: 20
TVP T50/51: 20
Foch 155: 20
AMX 50B: 20
Batchat 25t: 20
AMX 30B: 20
Waffentraiger: 20
Jagdpz E-100: 21 
Maus: 20
E-100: 21 I really love how the armor started working once i learnt to use angles and who doesnt love blapping people for 750 hp? Also EZ mode for HT missions, and incredibly fun overall tank
E-50M: 20
Leopard 1: 20
STB-1: 20
Type 5 Heavy: 14 I havent seen more than a couple that werent complete XP pinatas. As soon anyone "2-2's" armor its useless, and gun is also bad  
Centurion AX: 20
FV215b 183: 20
FV215b: 20
FV4005: 20
T57 Heavy: 20
T110E4: 20
T110E3: 20
M48 Patton: 20
T110E5: 20
Object 268: 20
Object 263: 20
T-62A: 20
Object 430: 20
Object 140: 20
IS-7: 20
IS-4: 20

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

21: 20
113: 20
TVP T50/51: 20
Foch 155: 20
AMX 50B: 20
Batchat 25t: 20
AMX 30B: 20
Waffentraiger: 17 played on the test server only but what a POS, everyone shoots you because paper, and if you don't die you get to read a blog while waiting for the reload

Jagdpz E-100: 21
Maus: 20
E-100: 22 alpha, hp, decent mobility, armor, what's not to love? <3
E-50M: 20
Leopard 1: 20
STB-1: 20
Type 5 Heavy: 14
Centurion AX: 20
FV215b 183: 20
FV215b: 20
FV4005: 20
T57 Heavy: 20
T110E4: 20
T110E3: 20
M48 Patton: 20
T110E5: 20
Object 268: 20
Object 263: 20
T-62A: 20
Object 430: 20
Object 140: 20
IS-7: 20
IS-4: 20

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

121: 20
113: 20
TVP T50/51: 20
Foch 155: 20
AMX 50B: 20
Batchat 25t: 20
AMX 30B: 20
Waffentraiger: 17 

Jagdpz E-100: 21
Maus: 20
E-100: 22 
E-50M: 20
Leopard 1: 20
STB-1: 20
Type 5 Heavy: 14
Centurion AX: 20
FV215b 183: 20
FV215b: 20
FV4005: 20
T57 Heavy: 20
T110E4: 20
T110E3: 20
M48 Patton: 20
T110E5: 21 Got overbuffed, gr8 pub tank, fighting GER super HT's are annoying but overall can bully most other tanks and faster than an e-100
Object 268: 17 seriously, this is worse than type 5 HT, the nerfs were to real and its literally like ew
Object 263: 20
T-62A: 20
Object 430: 20
Object 140: 20
IS-7: 20
IS-4: 20

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

121: 20
113: 20
TVP T50/51: 20
Foch 155: 20
AMX 50B: 20
Batchat 25t: 20
AMX 30B: 20
Waffentraiger: 17 

Jagdpz E-100: 21
Maus: 20
E-100: 22 
E-50M: 20
Leopard 1: 20
STB-1: 20
Type 5 Heavy: 11 Just a really bad tank overall. Slow, with armor that is easy to pen with gold shells and a mediocre gun, this tank just has no role on the battlefield.
Centurion AX: 20
FV215b 183: 20
FV215b: 20
FV4005: 20
T57 Heavy: 20
T110E4: 20
T110E3: 20
M48 Patton: 20
T110E5: 21 
Object 268: 
Object 263: 20
T-62A: 20
Object 430: 20
Object 140: 21 A really solid medium able to perform any role well, can do everything you need with a good top speed, great gun handling and workable armor. A really great tank overall
IS-7: 20
IS-4: 20

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

121: 20
113: 20
TVP T50/51: 20
Foch 155: 20
AMX 50B: 20
Batchat 25t: 20
AMX 30B: 20
Waffentraiger: 17 

Jagdpz E-100: 21
Maus: 17 Sure it has 3 grand in HP, but that quickly dwindles when exposed to the almighty HEAT round. Worse than the Type 5 in my opinion, though I don't play either.
E-100: 22 
E-50M: 20
Leopard 1: 20
STB-1: 20
Type 5 Heavy: 11
Centurion AX: 20
FV215b 183: 20
FV215b: 20
FV4005: 20
T57 Heavy: 20
T110E4: 20
T110E3: 20
M48 Patton: 20
T110E5: 21 
Object 268: 
Object 263: 20
T-62A: 21 Felt the 62A needed some love. Probably the best all-around medium tank in the game, good turret armor, accurate gun, high dpm, quick. I prefer playing the 140, but I feel the 62A is better overall.
Object 430: 20
Object 140: 21
IS-7: 20
IS-4: 20

 

PS. Lol at the E-100 being the top ranked at the moment, this can't be real.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

121: 20
113: 20
TVP T50/51: 20
Foch 155: 20
AMX 50B: 20
Batchat 25t: 20
AMX 30B: 20
Waffentraiger: 14 the undisputed king of one trick ponies, played three games and im not a camping fgt so guess how that went
Jagdpz E-100: 21
Maus: 20
E-100: 20
E-50M: 20
Leopard 1: 20
STB-1: 20
Type 5 Heavy: 11
Centurion AX: 20
FV215b 183: 20
FV215b: 20
FV4005: 20
T57 Heavy: 20
T110E4: 20
T110E3: 20
M48 Patton: 20
T110E5: 22 this tank makes every other tank in the game obsolete its just so all round amazing
Object 268: 20
Object 263: 20
T-62A: 20
Object 430: 20
Object 140: 21
IS-7: 20
IS-4: 20

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

121: 20
113: 20
TVP T50/51: 20
Foch 155: 20
AMX 50B: 21 Its just so gud. 325 apcr, 1600 clip and decent mobility.
Batchat 25t: 20
AMX 30B: 20
Waffentraiger: 14
Jagdpz E-100: 21
Maus: 20
E-100: 22
E-50M: 20
Leopard 1: 20
STB-1: 20
Type 5 Heavy: 11
Centurion AX: 20
FV215b 183: 20
FV215b: 20
FV4005: 17 stupid land arty, it's not even good it's just there to be a cancerous tank
T57 Heavy: 20
T110E4: 20
T110E3: 20
M48 Patton: 20
T110E5: 22
Object 268: 20
Object 263: 20
T-62A: 20
Object 430: 20
Object 140: 21
IS-7: 20
IS-4: 20

Edited by SkittlesOfSteeI
You saw nothing

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

121: 20
113: 20
TVP T50/51: 20
Foch 155: 20
AMX 50B: 21
Batchat 25t: 20
AMX 30B: 20
Waffentraiger: 14
Jagdpz E-100: 21
Maus: 20
E-100: 20
E-50M: 20
Leopard 1: 20
STB-1: 20
Type 5 Heavy: 8 seriously, whats the point? In choosing between this and the other 1 trick pony, the 4005, this one does it worse
Centurion AX: 20
FV215b 183: 20
FV215b: 21 The Meta-Proof warrior. Its a HT with MT DPM, and just enough of everything to make it a skilled players dream
FV4005: 17
T57 Heavy: 20
T110E4: 20
T110E3: 20
M48 Patton: 20
T110E5: 22
Object 268: 20
Object 263: 20
T-62A: 20
Object 430: 20
Object 140: 21
IS-7: 20
IS-4: 20

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

121: 20
113: 20
TVP T50/51: 20
Foch 155: 20
AMX 50B: 21
Batchat 25t: 20
AMX 30B: 20
Waffentraiger: 11 The entire premise behind this tank is dumb, it's neither fun to play nor play against
Jagdpz E-100: 21
Maus: 20
E-100: 20
E-50M: 20
Leopard 1: 21 Just really fun and comfortable to play, good gun with excellent speed and alpha.
STB-1: 20
Type 5 Heavy:
Centurion AX: 20
FV215b 183: 20
FV215b: 21
FV4005: 17
T57 Heavy: 20
T110E4: 20
T110E3: 20
M48 Patton: 20
T110E5: 22
Object 268: 20
Object 263: 20
T-62A: 20
Object 430: 20
Object 140: 21
IS-7: 20
IS-4: 20

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

121: 20
113: 20
TVP T50/51: 20
Foch 155: 20
AMX 50B: 22 -- great damage output, a more beefy T57.
Batchat 25t: 20
AMX 30B: 20
Waffentraiger: 11
Jagdpz E-100: 21
Maus: 20
E-100: 20
E-50M: 20
Leopard 1: 21
STB-1: 20
Type 5 Heavy: 5 This thing just looks like a piece of shit. Have not heard or seen anything good about it.
Centurion AX: 20
FV215b 183: 20

FV215b: 21
FV4005: 17
T57 Heavy: 20
T110E4: 20
T110E3: 20
M48 Patton: 20
T110E5: 22
Object 268: 20
Object 263: 20
T-62A: 20
Object 430: 20
Object 140: 21
IS-7: 20
IS-4: 20

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

121: 20
113: 20
TVP T50/51: 20
Foch 155: 20
AMX 50B: 22
Batchat 25t: 20
AMX 30B: 20
Waffentraiger: 11
Jagdpz E-100: 21
Maus: 20
E-100: 23 Still one hell of a pub carrier, especially since the map meta is going to corridors, a staple in tier 10 and pure fun. (also fixed the fact people forgot to carry on the +2 on it)
E-50M: 20
Leopard 1: 21
STB-1: 20
Type 5 Heavy: 2 Anything goes through it, gigantic, and barely more mobile than a maus, xp pinata.
Centurion AX: 20
FV215b 183: 20

FV215b: 21
FV4005: 17
T57 Heavy: 20
T110E4: 20
T110E3: 20
M48 Patton: 20
T110E5: 22
Object 268: 17
Object 263: 20
T-62A: 21
Object 430: 20
Object 140: 21
IS-7: 20
IS-4: 20

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

121: 20
113: 20
TVP T50/51: 20
Foch 155: 20
AMX 50B: 22
Batchat 25t: 20
AMX 30B: 20
Waffentraiger: 11
Jagdpz E-100: 21
Maus: 20
E-100: 24 carries super fucking hard, can take control of an entire flank and crush any opposition
E-50M: 20
Leopard 1: 21
STB-1: 20
Type 5 Heavy: 2
Centurion AX: 20
FV215b 183: 20

FV215b: 21
FV4005: 14 what a piece of fucking shit, all armor removed to be barely more mobile
T57 Heavy: 20
T110E4: 20
T110E3: 20
M48 Patton: 20
T110E5: 22
Object 268: 17
Object 263: 20
T-62A: 21
Object 430: 20
Object 140: 21
IS-7: 20
IS-4: 20

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

121: 20
113: 20
TVP T50/51: 20
Foch 155: 20
AMX 50B: 22
Batchat 25t: 20
AMX 30B: 20
Waffentraiger:
8 I really…really…really hate fighting these tanks, the camo is annoying and the auto loader basically makes short work out of anything before they have a chance to react to it
Jagdpz E-100: 21
Maus: 20
E-100: 24 carries
E-50M: 20
Leopard 1: 21
STB-1: 20
Type 5 Heavy: 2
Centurion AX: 20
FV215b 183: 20

FV215b: 21
FV4005: 14
T57 Heavy: 20
T110E4: 20
T110E3: 20
M48 Patton: 20
T110E5: 23 as well as being my first Tier X, it is also a very good jack of all trades heavy that has never let me down once (and im bad at this game XD)
Object 268: 17
Object 263: 20
T-62A: 21
Object 430: 20
Object 140: 21
IS-7: 20
IS-4: 20

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

121: 20
113: 20
TVP T50/51: 20
Foch 155: 20
AMX 50B: 22
Batchat 25t: 20
AMX 30B: 20
Waffentraiger:
 8
Jagdpz E-100: 21
Maus: 20
E-100: 24 carries
E-50M: 20
Leopard 1: 21
STB-1: 20
Type 5 Heavy: 2
Centurion AX: 20
FV215b 183: 20

FV215b: 21
FV4005: 11 It looks like trash, it smells like trash, it is trash. The only good thing about it is its cancerous gun which shouldn´t be in the game in the first place.
T57 Heavy: 20
T110E4: 20
T110E3: 20
M48 Patton: 20
T110E5: 24 It was very well balanced until WG with their great wisdom decided to effectivly remove its weakpoint while converting it into HD
Object 268: 17
Object 263: 20
T-62A: 21
Object 430: 20
Object 140: 21
IS-7: 20
IS-4: 20

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

121: 20
113: 20
TVP T50/51: 20
Foch 155: 20
AMX 50B: 22
Batchat 25t: 20
AMX 30B: 20
Waffentraiger:
 8
Jagdpz E-100: 21
Maus: 20
E-100: 24
E-50M: 20
Leopard 1: 21
STB-1: 20
Type 5 Heavy: -1, Sleep well my sweet prince, allow me to euthanize you like the gimped horse you are
Centurion AX: 20
FV215b 183: 20

FV215b: 21
FV4005: 11
T57 Heavy: 20
T110E4: 20
T110E3: 20
M48 Patton: 20
T110E5: 27, Obligatory +1. One of the better all rounders.
Object 263: 20
T-62A: 21
Object 430: 20
Object 140: 21
IS-7: 20
IS-4: 20

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

RIP type 5, you must be a real dog.. I would partake but I'm probably way out-dated.

Rexxie I am extremely disappointed that you discriminated against arty so harshly in this thread. :doge: 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

121: 20
113: 20
TVP T50/51: 20
Foch 155: 20
AMX 50B: 22

Batchat 25t: 21 It's the fastest tier 10 and one of the smallest which is a super fun combo. It has a terrifying damage output that can remove 2000 HP from any opponent it successfully ambushes. And on top of that it's still one of the best scouts in the game. This is the best tank to play if you're a cheeky cowardly French-loving bastard like me.
AMX 30B: 20
Waffentraiger: 5 Shit tank, not just unfun to play against but also unfun to play because its hideously massive design with a massive paper turret with horrible depression makes it downright painful to play aggressively. The reload time is utterly retarded too and it's not like the tank has the mobility to relocate during reloads like other autoloaders. It's a tank designed for shitty base camping, and designed to punish exposure and aggressive play in its adversaries, both bad things for the health of the game. Thank god WG is removing this pile of crap for the Grille 15.
Jagdpz E-100: 21
Maus: 20
E-100: 24 carries
E-50M: 20
Leopard 1: 21
STB-1: 20
Centurion AX: 20
FV215b 183: 20

FV215b: 21
FV4005: 11
T57 Heavy: 20
T110E4: 20
T110E3: 20
M48 Patton: 20

T110E5: 25
Object 263: 20
T-62A: 21
Object 430: 20
Object 140: 21
IS-7: 20
IS-4: 20

 

Edit: Fixed E5 points

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 minute ago, NoobestNoob said:

BTW, shoudlnt E5 have 25 pts?

 

So guys, T110E5 is not 27, but 25, because @Fabunil got confused and added 3 points instead of 1.

:kjugh: shamefur dispray

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

121: 20
113: 20
TVP T50/51: 20
Foch 155: 20
AMX 50B: 22

Batchat 25t: 
AMX 30B: 20
Waffentraiger: 5 
Jagdpz E-100: 21
Maus: 20
E-100: 24 
E-50M: 20
Leopard 1: 21
STB-1: 20
Centurion AX: 20
FV215b 183: 20

FV215b: 22 Best tank. 
FV4005: 11
T57 Heavy: 20
T110E4: 20
T110E3: 20
M48 Patton: 20

T110E5: 25
Object 263: 20
T-62A: 21
Object 430: 20

Object 140: 18 Fuck your hovermeds. 
IS-7: 20
IS-4: 20

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
17 minutes ago, PityFool said:

Rexxie I am extremely disappointed that you discriminated against arty so harshly in this thread. :doge: 

What's an "arty"? c:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.