Rexxie

Elimination: Tier 8 Premiums - Patriot's Providence (COMPLETE)

514 posts in this topic

Time for some post-Valentine's elimination. Time to take a look at the tanks our SOs made sure we can no longer afford!

It has been a while since we've had one of my elimination threads, so a quick reminder on how this works: Increase the best tank on the list by 1 and decrease the worst tank on the list by 3. Each user is allowed to do this a maximum of once per day. When a tank hits 0, it is eliminated. You must explain your choices, even if very briefly. Highlight your increase with GREEN and your decrease with RED if possible. If you cannot use colors, use BOLD for your upvotes and ITALICS for your downvotes. I'll keep track of what tanks are remaining and in what order they were eliminated. Remember to make sure you are copying the latest list before posting.

Since we're looking at both preferential and standard MM tanks, things are going to be a bit hairy this time around. I think it'll still be fun though, and splitting them up wouldn't give us much to talk about. Some extremely rare premiums have been removed - this includes the T95E2, KV-4 KTTS, Chieftain/T95, and unreleased RU clones. The fact almost no one has played these and can't vote based on personal experience makes them hard to judge.

1 TANK REMAINING

Type 59             ELIMINATED
WZ-111              ELIMINATED
112                 ELIMINATED
T-34-3              ELIMINATED
59-Patton           ELIMINATED
AMX CDC             ELIMINATED
FCM 50 t            ELIMINATED
M4A1 Rev.           ELIMINATED
AMX M4 49           ELIMINATED
leKpz M41 90mm      ELIMINATED
Skorpion            ELIMINATED
Panther 88          ELIMINATED
Lowe                ELIMINATED
Kanonenjagdpanzer   ELIMINATED
Pz. 58 Mutz         ELIMINATED
Jagdtiger 8.8cm     ELIMINATED
STA-2               ELIMINATED
FV4202 (P)          ELIMINATED
T26E4               ELIMINATED
T34                 ELIMINATED
M46 KR              ELIMINATED
T26E5 (Patriot)     VICTOR
T-54 Mod. 1         ELIMINATED
IS-6                ELIMINATED
KV-5                ELIMINATED
T-44-100            ELIMINATED

Elimination Order:

 
  1. Jagdtiger 8.8cm
  2. Kanonenjagdpanzer
  3. AMX CDC
  4. T-54 Mod. 1
  5. 59-Patton
  6. FV4202
  7. T34
  8. Panther 8.8
  9. IS-6
  10. FCM 50t
  11. leKpz M41 90mm
  12. T-44-100
  13. T-34-3
  14. KV-5
  15. WZ-111
  16. Type 59
  17. T26E4
  18. Pz. 58 Mutz
  19. STA-2
  20. M46 KR
  21. M4A1 Rev.
  22. Skorpion
  23. 112
  24. AMX M4 49
  25. Lowe

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Type 59 - 20


WZ-111 - 20
112 - 20
T-34-3 - 20
59-Patton - 20
AMX CDC - 20
FCM 50 t - 20
M4A1 Rev. - 20
AMX M4 49 - 20
leKpz M41 90mm - 20
Skorpion - 20
Panther 88 - 20
Lowe - 20
Kanonenjagdpanzer - 20
Pz. 58 Mutz - 20
Jagdtiger 8.8cm - 17 --- It's a low alpha casemate TD. Sure it shits credits and occasionally the armor works well but I'd rate it as the worst one here out of the ones I've played.
STA-2 - 20
FV4202 (P) - 20
Chieftain/T95 - 20
T26E4 - 20
T34 - 20
M6A2E1 - 20
T95E2 - 20
M46 KR - 21 --- Take and already excellent tank then dress it up as a tiger and have it produce gold.
T26E5 (Patriot) - 20
T-54 Mod. 1 - 20
IS-6 - 20
KV-5 - 20
T-44-100 - 20
IS-5 - 20
IS-3A - 20

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Type 59 - 20
WZ-111 - 20
112 - 20
T-34-3 - 20
59-Patton - 20
AMX CDC - 20
FCM 50 t - 20
M4A1 Rev. - 20
AMX M4 49 - 20
leKpz M41 90mm - 20
Skorpion - 20
Panther 88 - 20
Lowe - 20
Kanonenjagdpanzer - 20 - 3 = 17 Not much to say - it's the Kanonenjagdpanzer with its lackluster gun, no turret or armor.
Pz. 58 Mutz - 20
Jagdtiger 8.8cm - 17
STA-2 - 20 + 1 = 21 Really nice JOAT, great gun handling, DPM and nice mobility.
FV4202 (P) - 20
Chieftain/T95 - 20
T26E4 - 20
T34 - 20
T95E2 - 20
M46 KR - 21
T26E5 (Patriot) - 20
T-54 Mod. 1 - 20
IS-6 - 20
KV-5 - 20
T-44-100 - 20
IS-5 - 20
IS-3A - 20

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Could the next person remove the M6A2E1 from the list? It was one of the tanks that weren't supposed to be included, but I forgot to edit it out!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'm on mobile, can someone please put this in?

T26E4 +1 God tier medium. Slow, but one of the best armor layouts, good enough VR, good enough gun (esp after AP buff).

KV-5 -3: Too slow, armor is thick but weak spots on all sides make it unusable. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
2 minutes ago, Rexxie said:

Could the next person remove the M6A2E1 from the list? It was one of the tanks that weren't supposed to be included, but I forgot to edit it out!

Fixed it for you :)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
4 minutes ago, Rexxie said:

Could the next person remove the M6A2E1 from the list? It was one of the tanks that weren't supposed to be included, but I forgot to edit it out!

Ur a bot, you forgot to remove the chieftain/t95 and the t95e2. 

Edit: I'd also argue the IS-3A is rare enough to not be counted in the list. 

Edited by Luna

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 minute ago, Luna said:

Ur a bot, you forgot to remove the chieftain/t95 and the t95e2. 

Lmao what a pubbie, fixed. Here's the current list:

Type 59 - 20
WZ-111 - 20
112 - 20
T-34-3 - 20
59-Patton - 20
AMX CDC - 20
FCM 50 t - 20
M4A1 Rev. - 20
AMX M4 49 - 20
leKpz M41 90mm - 20
Skorpion - 20
Panther 88 - 20
Lowe - 20
Kanonenjagdpanzer - 17
Pz. 58 Mutz - 20
Jagdtiger 8.8cm - 17
STA-2 - 21
FV4202 (P) - 20
T26E4 - 21
T34 - 20
M46 KR - 21
T26E5 (Patriot) - 20
T-54 Mod. 1 - 20
IS-6 - 20
KV-5 - 17
T-44-100 - 20
IS-5 - 20
IS-3A - 20

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Type 59 - 20
WZ-111 - 20
112 - 20
T-34-3 - 20
59-Patton - 20
AMX CDC - 20
FCM 50 t - 20
M4A1 Rev. - 20
AMX M4 49 - 20
leKpz M41 90mm - 20
Skorpion - 20
Panther 88 - 20
Lowe - 21 :This tank is the new meta
Kanonenjagdpanzer -  14 Looking at this list, this is the one I'd lie to play least atm
Pz. 58 Mutz - 20
Jagdtiger 8.8cm - 17
STA-2 - 21
FV4202 (P) - 20
T26E4 - 21 Luna: God tier medium. Slow, but one of the best armor layouts, good enough VR, good enough gun (esp after AP buff).
T34 - 20
M46 KR - 21
T26E5 (Patriot) - 20
T-54 Mod. 1 - 20
IS-6 - 20
KV-5 - 17 - Luna: Too slow, armor is thick but weak spots on all sides make it unusable. 
T-44-100 - 20
IS-5 - 20
IS-3A - 20

 

Updated w/ Lunas picks

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Wow, I'm fucking slow.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Just now, Rexxie said:

Lmao what a pubbie, fixed. Here's the current list:

Snip

Read my edit pls and give opinion

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

@Errants you can add your picks, my post contains Luna's info/feedback w/ proper math 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Type59 - 20
WZ-111 - 20
112 - 20
T-34-3 - 20 -3 = 17 Bad depression and gun handling makes this my least favorite tank on this list
59-Patton - 20
AMX CDC - 20
FCM 50 t - 20
M4A1 Rev. - 20
AMX M4 49 - 20
leKpz M41 90mm - 20
Skorpion - 20 
Panther 88 - 20
Lowe - 21 
Kanonenjagdpanzer -  14
Pz. 58 Mutz - 20
Jagdtiger 8.8cm - 17
STA-2 - 21
FV4202 (P) - 20
T26E4 - 21
T34 - 20
M46 KR - 21
T26E5 (Patriot) - 20
T-54 Mod. 1 - 20
IS-6 - 20
KV-5 - 17 +1 = 18: Best all round curbstomper and lol dpmer there  is 
T-44-100 - 20
IS-5 - 20
IS-3A - 20

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
3 minutes ago, TheMarine0341 said:

@Errants you can add your picks, my post contains Luna's info/feedback w/ proper math 

I've picked up on that... fuck, I'm glacial... guess I should stop trying to eat... and picking the right colors is rough, waiting for tool-tips telling me which one is what.

Type 59 - 20
WZ-111 - 20
112 - 20
T-34-3 - 17
59-Patton - 20
AMX CDC - 20
FCM 50 t - 20
M4A1 Rev. - 20
AMX M4 49 - 20
leKpz M41 90mm - 20 + 1 = 21  - A scout that makes credits and isn't gimped (AMX 13 57/Type 62), and the HEP shells are GLORIOUS for counterscouting.
Skorpion - 20
Panther 88 - 20
Lowe - 21 
Kanonenjagdpanzer -  14 - 3 = 11 - I've yet to hear ANYTHING positive about this tank, except from the Wheraboo Finn.  Have not played it myself, though.
Pz. 58 Mutz - 20
Jagdtiger 8.8cm - 17
STA-2 - 21
FV4202 (P) - 20
T26E4 - 21
T34 - 20
M46 KR - 21
T26E5 (Patriot) - 20
T-54 Mod. 1 - 20
IS-6 - 20
KV-5 - 18
T-44-100 - 20
IS-5 - 20
IS-3A - 20

Edited by Errants
FINALLY

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 minute ago, Luna said:

@Errants kv5 supposed to be 14, super P 22. 

ITS -3!!!!

He was just posting yours, although yeah, it's -3.

IS-3A is probably fine, it's 5x more common than the T95E2/T95/etc and even more common than the standard T8 frenchie TD lmao.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
6 minutes ago, Joyrider216 said:

T-34-3 - 20 -3 = 17 Bad depression and gun handling makes this my least favorite tank on this list

The T-34-3 got buffed to 5 degrees of gun depression at some point.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Type 59 - 20
WZ-111 - 20
112 - 20
T-34-3 - 17
59-Patton - 20
AMX CDC - 20
FCM 50 t - 20
M4A1 Rev. - 20 + 1 = 21 Sweet 390 alpha on a medium tank? After a great buff one of the best and special prem tanks.
AMX M4 49 - 20
leKpz M41 90mm -  21
Skorpion - 20
Panther 88 - 20
Lowe - 21 
Kanonenjagdpanzer -  11
Pz. 58 Mutz - 20
Jagdtiger 8.8cm - 17
STA-2 - 21
FV4202 (P) - 20 - 3 = 17 Bad... everything. No armor, speed, mobility, real gun. Worse Centurion I, that's all.
T26E4 - 21
T34 - 20
M46 KR - 21
T26E5 (Patriot) - 20
T-54 Mod. 1 - 20
IS-6 - 20
KV-5 - 18
T-44-100 - 20
IS-5 - 20
IS-3A - 20

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Just now, Whole_Nutjob said:

The T-34-3 got buffed to 5 degrees of gun depression at some point.

I only ever played it post buff, and I still didn't enjoy it, @leggasiini this is probably the only tank I truly dislike. :doge: 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 minute ago, Joyrider216 said:

I only ever played it post buff, and I still didn't enjoy it, @leggasiini this is probably the only tank I truly dislike. :doge: 

Oh ok, by bad gun depression I thought you were referring to the old values, no the current ones.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Oh sweet, elimination thread :P

Imo we should at some point redo tier 10 elimination after month or two, just for science. Im pretty sure the results would be quite different (E5 wouldnt win for sure anymore)

Type 59 - 20
WZ-111 - 20
112 - 20
T-34-3 - 17
59-Patton - 20
AMX CDC - 20
FCM 50 t - 20
M4A1 Rev. - 21
AMX M4 49 - 20
leKpz M41 90mm -  21
Skorpion - 20
Panther 88 - 20
Lowe - 21 
Kanonenjagdpanzer -  11 - 3 = 8. Lets get this shit out; its not even tier 8, its tier 7 with scout mm!!!
Pz. 58 Mutz - 20
Jagdtiger 8.8cm - 17
STA-2 - 21
FV4202 (P) - 17
T26E4 - 21
T34 - 20
M46 KR - 21
T26E5 (Patriot) - 20
T-54 Mod. 1 - 20
IS-6 - 20
KV-5 - 18 + 1 = 19. This shit is so fun to play and arguably best yolotank in the game. I got 70% WR on mine after 200 battles, with about half solo so go figure :P 
T-44-100 - 20
IS-5 - 20
IS-3A - 20

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
8 minutes ago, leggasiini said:

Oh sweet, elimination thread :P

Imo we should at some point redo tier 10 elimination after month or two, just for science. Im pretty sure the results would be quite different (E5 wouldnt win for sure anymore)

Type 59 - 20
WZ-111 - 20
112 - 20
T-34-3 - 17
59-Patton - 20
AMX CDC - 20
FCM 50 t - 20
M4A1 Rev. - 21
AMX M4 49 - 20
leKpz M41 90mm -  21
Skorpion - 20
Panther 88 - 20
Lowe - 21 
Kanonenjagdpanzer -  11 - 3 = 8. Lets get this shit out; its not even tier 8, its tier 7 with scout mm!!!
Pz. 58 Mutz - 20
Jagdtiger 8.8cm - 17
STA-2 - 21
FV4202 (P) - 17
T26E4 - 21
T34 - 20
M46 KR - 21
T26E5 (Patriot) - 20
T-54 Mod. 1 - 20
IS-6 - 20
KV-5 - 18 + 1 = 19. This shit is so fun to play and arguably best yolotank in the game. I got 70% WR on mine after 200 battles, with about half solo so go figure :P 
T-44-100 - 20
IS-5 - 20
IS-3A - 20

There. Color. :kappaross:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

alright lessgo

Type 59 - 20
WZ-111 - 20
112 - 20
T-34-3 - 17
59-Patton - 20-1=19 I literally feel sorry for people who spent money on this thing. 
AMX CDC - 20
FCM 50 t - 20+1=21 okay, heres my thinking: as a prem tank, grinding credits is pretty much the primary task of the tank. so for me personally, I won't buy a prem tank for that purpose without pref MM, since grinding credits is already tedious, doing it without pref MM is just aids, so counting out non pref tanks, the best pref MM tank here is easily the FCM, both to play, and to print credits (tanks like SP and IS-6 rely too much on gold to make good money)
M4A1 Rev. - 21
AMX M4 49 - 20
leKpz M41 90mm -  21
Skorpion - 20
Panther 88 - 20
Lowe - 21 
Kanonenjagdpanzer - 8
Pz. 58 Mutz - 20
Jagdtiger 8.8cm - 17
STA-2 - 21
FV4202 (P) - 17
T26E4 - 21
T34 - 20
M46 KR - 21
T26E5 (Patriot) - 20
T-54 Mod. 1 - 20
IS-6 - 20
KV-5 - 19 
T-44-100 - 20
IS-3A - 20

 

Footnote: I also removed the IS-5 because reward tank, I figured. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.